Seafood in St Pete Beach

Seafood pairs buttery sauces with bright lemon flavors at Carino's Nuovo in St Pete Beach, FL, where you can order pickup.

Order online

Popular Seafood to Try

Saffron Risotto & Scallops

$39.00

Seared scallops top saffron risotto with spinach and lobster butter.

“The absolute best scallop risotto I've ever had in my entire life. such an amazing atmosphere manager to worry. there really just makes everything better. his weight staff is amazing. actually got a chance to meet the owner. really nice guy. such a great place to go for a nice dinner with a loved one or a nice date night dinner. I took my girl there while she was in from out of town and with her and her friends and we just had the most amazing experience there. would definitely go again and again”

Butter-Poached Lobster Risotto

$39.00

Herbed risotto has butter-poached lobster, mushrooms, and tomato pesto.

“Excellent lobster! Service was great!”

Pesto-Crusted Red Snapper

$35.00

Pan-seared snapper with pesto crust, pappardelle, and broccolini.

“It was a very chill place. The live piano player gave it an amazing vibe... The food was delish we had the pesto crusted red snapper. It was just great and the stuffed mushroom were great... Definitely will come back”

Prepared the Carino's Nuovo Way

At Carino's Nuovo, seafood pairs seared tuna with Chianti glaze and watermelon, while butter-poached lobster tail joins creamy herbed risotto with oyster mushrooms, sun-dried tomato pesto, and lemon herb butter.

Saffron Garlic Stuffed Shrimp holds artichokes and Parmesan. Pesto-Crusted Red Snapper comes with house-made pappardelle. Saffron Risotto & Scallops features U-10 seared scallops and lobster butter.

Join us in St Pete Beach, FL, for dine-in, or order pickup or delivery. Lemon Butter Shrimp Scampi features colossal shrimp sautéed in house lemon butter and served with house-made garlic bread.

Seafood to Try

Peppercrusted Ahi Tuna

$17.00

Seared pepper-crusted tuna comes with watermelon and Chianti glaze.

“We recently had my husbands birthday dinner here. The food, service, and ambiance was so good. Literally everything we ordered on the menu was so delicious. Honorable mentions, ahi tuna, octopus, stuffed mushrooms, squid ink pasta, lobster risotto, Italian bread pudding. The servers were very accommodating and made sure we were having a good time.”

Lemon Butter Shrimp Scampi

$15.00

Sautéed shrimp in lemon butter are served with house-made garlic bread.

“I’m very picky about Italian restaurants, and me and my group all enjoyed our entrees. Must say, though, the apps were verrry good — stuffed mushrooms, shrimp scampi (perfect doneness), & buratta apps were all excellent.”

Saffron Garlic Stuffed Shrimp

$16.00

Shrimp stuffed with artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes, herbs, and Parmesan.

“We loved our waitress Heather and the meal was delicious!! Just like from Chicagos little Italy. Some had fish, some had veal, one has chicken Marsala. All was outstanding!!”

Gulf Grouper Involtini

$39.00

Red grouper is stuffed with crab, olives, peppers, and leeks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular seafood options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Saffron Risotto & Scallops — Creamy saffron risotto is topped with seared scallops, garlic-sautéed spinach, lobster butter, and a delicate egg-yolk garnish.
Butter-Poached Lobster Risotto — Creamy risotto is served with butter-poached lobster tail, oyster mushrooms, sun-dried tomato pesto, and lemon-herb butter.
Gulf Grouper Involtini — Stuffed grouper combines crab, Parmesan, olives, peppers, and leeks, served with black garlic purée, broccolini, and ricotta mashed potatoes.
Pesto-Crusted Red Snapper — Skin-on red snapper has a sun-dried tomato pesto crust, with pappardelle, roasted tomato butternut squash sauce, and broccolini.
Peppercrusted Ahi Tuna — Ahi tuna is seared with a pepper crust and served with watermelon, marinated radish, arugula, and black garlic purée.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for seafood throughout the St Pete Beach area. Order your seafood online for convenient pickup or delivery.